Notes:
- The coelacanth is a fish once believed to have gone extinct 66 million years ago.
- In 1938, a living coelacanth was discovered off the coast of South Africa.
- Coelacanths can grow up to 6 feet long and weigh nearly 200 pounds.
- They live at depths of 500 to 800 feet in underwater caves.
Goal: Emphasize the surprising nature of the 1938 discovery.
Analysis: To emphasize surprise, the sentence must set up the expectation (believed extinct for 66 million years) and then reveal the surprise (found alive in 1938).
Correct: "Although scientists had believed the coelacanth had been extinct for 66 million years, a living specimen was discovered off the coast of South Africa in 1938."
Wrong: "Coelacanths can grow up to 6 feet long and live in underwater caves at depths of 500 to 800 feet." (Accurate but irrelevant to the goal of emphasizing surprise.)
3 quick checks in this lesson
Check 1 of 3
Notes: Many researchers assumed insects had no sense of number at all. In a 2018 study, honeybees learned to rank an empty display as having fewer items than a display with one item. Honeybee brains contain fewer than one million neurons. The goal is to emphasize the surprising nature of the 2018 finding. Which sentence does that?
Arctic permafrost contains an estimated 1,500 billion tons of organic carbon — nearly twice the amount currently in the atmosphere. _______, as global temperatures rise, thawing permafrost could release massive quantities of methane and carbon dioxide, potentially accelerating climate change.
Analysis: The first sentence establishes a fact (permafrost holds enormous carbon). The second sentence explains the implication (thawing could release it). This is a cause/effect or consequence relationship.
Correct: "As a result" or "Consequently" — the risk of release is a consequence of the carbon being there combined with warming.
Wrong: "However" (no contrast). "For example" (the second sentence isn't an example of the first). "Similarly" (no parallel is being drawn).
Notes:
- Kintsugi is a Japanese art form dating to the 15th century.
- Broken pottery is repaired using lacquer mixed with powdered gold.
- The visible golden seams highlight rather than hide the object's history of damage.
- The practice reflects a philosophical embrace of imperfection and transience.
Goal: Introduce kintsugi to an audience unfamiliar with it.
Analysis: For an unfamiliar audience, the sentence should define what kintsugi IS and give a basic description. Technical or philosophical details come second.
Correct: "Kintsugi is a Japanese art form, dating to the 15th century, in which broken pottery is repaired with gold-infused lacquer, creating visible seams that highlight the object's history."
Wrong: "The philosophical embrace of imperfection and transience is central to the practice." (This assumes the reader already knows what the practice is.)
Check 2 of 3
Notes: The theremin is an electronic instrument invented by Léon Theremin in 1920. A performer plays it without touching it, moving their hands near two antennas. It was used in many 1950s science-fiction film soundtracks. The goal is to introduce the theremin to an audience unfamiliar with it. Which sentence does that?
The proposed highway would reduce commute times by an estimated 25 minutes for thousands of workers. _______, environmental advocates argue that the project would destroy 300 acres of wetland habitat critical to migratory bird populations.
Analysis: The first sentence presents a benefit. The second presents a drawback. The relationship is contrast in the form of a concession: the text grants the benefit, then turns to a concern. A transition that grants the first point and then turns against it captures that turn. A contrast word with a different meaning does not: "Instead" signals a replacement, and "On the contrary" says the first claim is false.
Correct: "Nevertheless", "However" or "On the other hand": each one pivots from the benefit to the concern. A real SAT item would offer only one of the three. The other choices would signal a different relationship (a result, an example, a similarity, an addition), or be a contrast word with the wrong meaning, such as "Instead".
Check 3 of 3
Which transition most logically completes the text?
The new vaccine was 95% effective in clinical trials. _______, it must be stored at −70°C, which makes it difficult to distribute in rural areas.