The five qualities behind the holistic score, each shown done badly and done well, plus four myths that waste preparation time.
An open book beside a notebook and pen
Credit: Photo from Unsplash
A reader forms one overall judgment, and five qualities move it. Each can be practiced. By the end of this lesson you will be able to name the five, recognize each done well and badly, and drop four myths that waste preparation time.
| Quality | In plain words | The reader's question |
|---|---|---|
| Position | A clear stance that answers the specific task | What does this writer think, and did they do what was asked? |
| Development | Reasons backed by explained examples | Does each example actually show the point? |
| Organization | A focused argument whose ideas connect | Can I follow how each part leads to the next? |
| Language | Precise wording, varied sentences | Does the prose say exactly what is meant? |
| Conventions | Control of standard written English | Do errors ever make me reread? |
They are not sub-scores added together, and weakness in one drags on the others. Every example below answers one original prompt:
"Workplaces that let employees choose their own hours get better results than workplaces that set fixed schedules."
Judge how sound this statement is. Test it against cases that bear it out and cases that defeat it, and let those cases decide your stand.
Weak: There are many advantages and disadvantages to flexible hours, and every workplace is different.
True, and not a position. It notices complexity without deciding which cases bear the statement out and which defeat it, which is what this instruction asks.
Strong: Letting employees choose their hours usually improves results in work judged by its finished output, such as editing, but backfires where the work depends on people being present together, as in a restaurant kitchen.
A reader could disagree with this, and its built-in condition delivers what the instruction demands. A qualified position is not a hedge when it names the dividing line.
Weak: For example, many tech companies have flexible hours and they are very successful. Also, flexible hours make people happier.
The example is generic (which companies, doing what?) and unexplained: success has many causes, and nothing links it to the hours. "Happier" is asserted, not connected to results.
Strong: Consider a small translation agency whose translators each handle separate documents. If one does her sharpest work from six until noon and another from two until eight, the agency loses nothing by letting them, because each file is judged only on accuracy and deadline. Give the same freedom to a kitchen crew and the dinner rush is half-staffed.
Specific, analyzed (it says why the freedom costs nothing) and tied back to the thesis's condition. A clearly described, plausible case can serve as an example if you explain what it shows; the explanation is what readers look for.
2 quick checks in this lesson
Check 1 of 2
Which revision best develops the weak sentence "For example, many tech companies have flexible hours and they are very successful"?
Weak: Flexible schedules help people who are most alert in the morning. Many people also prefer working from home, which saves commuting costs. Housing near city centers is expensive, so long commutes are common.
Each sentence follows the last, yet the paragraph slides from hours to remote work and housing. Links between neighboring sentences are not focus.
Strong: Flexible hours pay off most clearly when output can be judged without watching the worker. A report is accurate or not, whenever it was written, so a manager who can judge the report need not judge the hours behind it. That is why the case weakens as work becomes collaborative: in a staffed shift, timing is part of the output itself.
The first sentence states the claim, every later sentence advances it, and "That is why" signals a logical step back to the thesis's condition.
Weak: Flexible hours are good. They make workers happy. Happy workers do good work. This is good for companies.
Strong: Workers who control their schedules tend to arrive rested rather than resentful, and rested people make fewer of the small errors that quietly cost a business money.
The weak version repeats one short sentence shape and uses "good" three times without saying anything exact. The strong one offers a concrete contrast and a precise consequence. Precision means the right ordinary word, not the rarest one.
Weak: Its clear that employee's who sets there own hours works harder, they dont need to be watched.
Corrected: It's clear that employees who set their own hours work harder; they don't need to be watched.
The weak sentence has seven errors: "Its", "employee's", "sets", "there", "works", a comma splice and "dont". Minor slips are tolerated even at the top of the scale; what costs you is frequency, and errors that force a reread. With no spell-checker, you are the only proofreader.
Run each practice paragraph through a reader's questions in order:
| Myth | Why it fails | Instead |
|---|---|---|
| Big words impress | A rare word used slightly wrongly blurs meaning | Use the exact everyday word |
| Exactly five paragraphs | Organization should fit the argument; strong essays usually run four or five because development needs room | Let your reasons set the count |
| Longer is better | Length is not scored as such; padding weakens focus | Add development, not words |
| There is a right side | Agree, disagree and qualify are all acceptable | Take the position you can support best |
Trap: fixing the wrong thing. An essay short on development needs explained examples, not more vocabulary or more paragraphs.
Check 2 of 2
A practice essay makes two well-developed points across four paragraphs. A friend says it needs five paragraphs to score well. What is the best response?