What the prompt contains, what the task requires, how the 2–12 writing score is built from two readers and four domains, and what that score does and does not affect.
A student taking a timed test on a laptop, focused and calm
Credit: Photo from Unsplash
After this reading you will be able to say what the ACT writing prompt contains, what your essay must do, how two readers turn it into a score from 2 to 12, and what that score does and does not touch.
The writing test is optional and comes after the multiple-choice sections. You get one prompt and 40 minutes, with no choice of topic.
The prompt has two parts:
The booklet also gives you planning space with prewriting questions. Use it, but know that planning is not scored — the readers score only the essay.
Here is an original prompt we will use throughout this module.
Course Reviews. Students often pick an elective knowing little more than its title. Imagine your school board is deciding whether to publish anonymous reviews written by students who have already taken each course. Should a school publish student reviews of its courses?
Perspective One: Students are the ones who sit through a course. Publishing their reviews gives everyone better information and pushes weak courses to improve.
Perspective Two: Reviews measure popularity, not learning. A demanding course could be rated below an easy one, and teachers would feel pressure to make classes easier.
Perspective Three: Reviews should go privately to teachers, who can use them to improve without turning courses into a ratings contest.
The task packs three jobs into one unified, coherent essay. You must:
Your perspective may agree with one of the three, agree in part, or be entirely different; there is no correct side. Arguing that reviews should be published only if they ask what students learned is a view of your own: it borrows from Perspective One, takes Perspective Two's worry seriously, and goes beyond both.
"Analyze the relationship" is the phrase students most often skip. It means explaining where your view and another meet, where they part, and why. Describing a perspective is not analyzing it.
| What the essay does | Meets the task? |
|---|---|
| Summarizes all three perspectives and calls each one fair | No: no view of its own |
| Argues a view and never mentions any perspective | No: no relationship analyzed |
| Copies Perspective One's claim in longer sentences | No: restates, does not analyze |
| States a view, then shows where Perspective Two is right and why it still falls short | Yes |
2 quick checks in this lesson
Check 1 of 2
A student responding to the Course Reviews prompt plans three body paragraphs, one explaining each perspective, and a conclusion saying all three raise fair points. What is the main problem with this plan?
Trap: treating the perspectives as a reading-comprehension exercise. The readers know what they say; restating them earns nothing, while using them to sharpen your argument earns a great deal.
Planning, writing and checking all share the same 40 minutes. Plan for 20 and you get a fine outline, which is not scored, and a half-finished essay; plan for none and you may find halfway through that you disagree with your own opening. Module 3 gives you a budget. For now, treat the clock as part of the task.
Two trained readers each give your essay a score from 1 to 6 in each of four domains: Ideas and Analysis, Development and Support, Organization, and Language Use and Conventions. The next reading explains what each one rewards. Here is the arithmetic:
Worked example. Reader A gives 4, 4, 3, 4 across the four domains in the order listed above. Reader B gives 4, 4, 3, 3. No domain differs by more than one point, so no third reader is needed.
Domain scores: 4 + 4 = 8, 4 + 4 = 8, 3 + 3 = 6 and 4 + 3 = 7. Sum: 8 + 8 + 6 + 7 = 29. Average: 29 ÷ 4 = 7.25, which rounds to a writing score of 7.
If both readers had given Organization a 4 instead, the sum would be 31, and 31 ÷ 4 = 7.75 rounds to 8. All four domains count equally, so your weakest domain is usually your cheapest point to gain.
Check 2 of 2
Reader A scores an essay 5, 4, 4 and 3 in Ideas and Analysis, Development and Support, Organization, and Language Use and Conventions. Reader B scores the same domains 5, 4, 3 and 4. What is the writing score?
The writing score does not change your Composite score or any multiple-choice section score; it is reported on its own.
Some colleges and programs ask for the writing score, and requirements differ, so check each college's own admissions information. If any college on your list asks for it, take it; if your list is still taking shape, taking it keeps more doors open.